Let’s be honest.
We’ve all worked with that manager. The one who makes every team meeting feel like a Game of Thrones battle scene. Or worse, the one who smiles while slowly draining your will to work.
But toxic leadership isn’t always that obvious. It’s not always screaming matches and slamming doors. Sometimes, it’s quiet. Subtle. Disguised as “high standards” or “just the way we do things around here.”
So how do you spot toxic leadership before you start dreaming about quitting your job to raise alpacas in Tasmania?
Let’s break it down.
First: What is Toxic Leadership, Anyway?
Toxic leadership is a pattern of behavior from someone in a position of power that harms the people, culture, or performance of a team. It might not be intended to hurt—but it still does.
Some common traits:
- Control over trust
- Fear over safety
- Blame over accountability
- Ego over empathy
And here’s the kicker: It’s not just “bad bosses.” Anyone in a leadership position (formal or informal) can show toxic traits—even the well-meaning ones.
What It Looks Like—In Real Life
Let’s paint a few scenes. See if any feel familiar.
Scene 1: Micromanager Mayhem
Your manager assigns a task, then asks for updates every hour. They rewrite your work “just to help” and override decisions you’ve made without a conversation. You start second-guessing everything—even your lunch order.
Scene 2: Feedback Freeze
You haven’t had a 1:1 in months. When you ask for feedback, it’s vague (“You’re doing fine”). Then suddenly, you’re told you’re “not meeting expectations”—and you’re blindsided.
Scene 3: Mood Roulette
Some days your manager is warm and collaborative. Other days, they barely speak, or snap at everyone. You spend more time managing their emotions than your actual job.
Scene 4: Credit Theft Club
You nail a presentation. They present your work as their own. You smile through gritted teeth because, “That’s just how it is, right?”
Nope. That’s how burnout starts.
If You’re a Manager: 3 Ways to Check Yourself (Without Spiraling)
This part isn’t about shame. It’s about awareness.
1. Ask for honest feedback
Create anonymous pulse checks. Ask your team what they need more or less of from you. Be ready to listen without defending.
2. Audit your 1:1s
Are they coaching sessions or status updates? Do your team members leave feeling more confident—or more confused?
3. Say “I don’t know” sometimes
You don’t have to be the all-knowing boss. You just have to be a trustworthy one. Vulnerability builds trust way faster than perfection ever will.
If You’re an Employee: How to Protect Your Peace (and Your Power)
You might not be able to change your manager, but you can change your approach.
1. Document everything (not in a petty way, in a self-protective way)
Keep track of what you’ve worked on, feedback you’ve received, and any questionable moments. It’s your professional paper trail.
2. Find safe spaces to vent and strategize
This could be a mentor, a peer in another department, or a professional coach. Talking it out helps you separate facts from feelings.
3. Focus on what you can control
This includes your reactions, boundaries, and how you take care of yourself outside work. Toxic leadership doesn’t get to rent space in your head 24/7.
Let’s Talk Solutions (and Not Just Survival)
This is the part where you might expect a magical “just do this” tip. But here’s the truth: tackling toxic leadership takes culture-wide effort.
If you’re in HR or people ops:
Create systems for anonymous reporting and psychological safety. Promote leaders based on EQ, not just output.
If you’re an exec:
Model the behaviors you want to see. Your team watches how you respond to mistakes more than they watch how you celebrate wins.
Final Word: You Deserve Better
Toxic leadership isn’t just “part of the job.”
It’s a problem—and it’s one we can solve together. Whether you’re leading a team or just trying to survive one, there are tools, communities, and conversations (like this one) that can help.
Let’s build a better workplace, one honest convo at a time.
Over to you:
Have you ever worked with (or for) a toxic leader? What did you learn?
Drop your story in the comments or DM us if you want to share privately.
#ElevatePx #ToxicLeadership #LeadershipMatters #PeopleFirst #ManagerTools
Discover more from ElevatePx
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


